Sign in to follow this  
ricksconnected

which is better in your opinion and why?

Recommended Posts

ok lets create a shtf situation.

 

say you have a situation where a soldier is given a direct order to do something.

ok now, the order is clearly wrong and against the constitution as well, but it is a given order

though. which is the better, the soldier that clearly sees the situation and refuses to comply, or the soldier that keeps his/her feelings out of it and follows the direct command and why?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ok lets create a shtf situation.

 

say you have a situation where a soldier is given a direct order to do something.

ok now, the order is clearly wrong and against the constitution as well, but it is a given order

though. which is the better, the soldier that clearly sees the situation and refuses to comply, or the soldier that keeps his/her feelings out of it and follows the direct command and why?

 

Isn't this what the Nazis said"I was just following orders".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can morally object to a lawful order, wisdom tells me that, if it's not illegal, I must follow it. Wisdom would also tell me to get that order in writing, signed, and witnessed to CMA. If it does end up being illegal, I'm covered, if not, I have an autograph. If it is a legal order this is a small hassle, if not they'll find another patsy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I can morally object to a lawful order, wisdom tells me that, if it's not illegal, I must follow it. Wisdom would also tell me to get that order in writing, signed, and witnessed to CMA. If it does end up being illegal, I'm covered, if not, I have an autograph. If it is a legal order this is a small hassle, if not they'll find another patsy.

 

EXACTLY!!!!

You can either be a man and stand up for right or you can do like Hitler's minions and hide behind the orders excuse. Of course neither course is pleasant. There is only one that I can live with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ok lets create a shtf situation.

 

say you have a situation where a soldier is given a direct order to do something.

ok now, the order is clearly wrong and against the constitution as well, but it is a given order

though. which is the better, the soldier that clearly sees the situation and refuses to comply, or the soldier that keeps his/her feelings out of it and follows the direct command and why?

 

I would get it in writing, disobey it turn copies over to IG and JAG if persisted on then the media and if possible if it is an individual take them into custody if systemic I am no longer bound by contract or law to obey or serve under them... My oath is to the constitution and by proxy the people to obey those lawfully appointed over me an unconstitutional order nulifies their authority.. I walk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was never in the military so I hope I'm not speaking out of turn. I heard an interview on the radio a few weeks ago with a guy, (I can't remember his name) who is either the founder - or one of the co-founders - of a movement within the military called "Oath Keepers" that addresses this very subject. These guys, (and gals) vowed to keep their oath to protect the constitution and not follow illegal orders. I have a lot of respect for these people.

Edited by PatzerDave

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have to agree 400% with Warrior. I made my feelings on this pretty open in the NRA News thread in the firearms forum.

An illegal order is just that and I will NOT follow it. We have all paid too high a price to throw away our morals, ethics and the Constitution which we hold so dear and true to our hearts.

 

Now if you want to have fun... ask your local official why they fly an American flag with the gold border? This is the "federal" flag and represents federal authority, aka, martial law. I will bet not many (if any) will even know that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I was never in the military so I hope I'm not speaking out of turn. I heard an interview on the radio a few weeks ago with a guy, (I can't remember his name) who is either the founder - or one of the co-founders - of a movement within the military called "Oath Keepers" that addresses this very subject. These guys, (and gals) vowed to keep their oath to protect the constitution and not follow illegal orders. I have a lot of respect for these people.

 

It's for active duty as well as veterans as well and any current or former LEO's. I am a member.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ok guys but the thing is, when your out in the bush you dont always have the option or time to get something in writing ya know.

 

Then I go through the chain of command. If I don't have that option I refuse.

 

Out in Colorado, while in the MP's, we were alerted on a Saturday morning after a snowstorm. A state of emergency was declared and we were asked to help stranded motorists. I ran down to the motor pool started my Humvee and went to the bay to get further instructions.

 

My LT told us she needed ten drivers with snow driving experience, and the rest would start working on the next platoons' humvees, I raised my hand, being a Michigander, everyone else was from a southern state. She looked at me and said "if I have anything to say about it, Hoffmann's not driving.". My team leader argued with her because he and the rest of the NCOs knew I could do anything asked of me, but she wouldn't change her stance. I looked in the eye, smiled, and said "then I don't need to be here ma'am." and walked out.

 

I prayed that I would get a counciling statement, (a written disciplinary note in my file), over this. It never came.

 

Later, in Bosnia, we were working road duty on Tuzla airbase, when my duty partner got swapped to from a private to a specialist. I didn't think much about it until a friend, who slept in the platoon sergeants tent pulled me aside one day and explained that the platoon sergeant thought I was incompetent and wanted someone to assure I didn't mess anything up.

 

A week or so later, we were called out secure a scene for CID, criminal investigation division, I responded with "good copy, are you sure you want to send me, sgt _____ thought I was incompetent," that didn't go over well. I was told to return to station and then told to expect a counciling statement that evening.

 

After shift, my desk sergeant, also my team leader, asked why I said that over the radio knowing that everyone up the camp commander listened to that channel? I told him that if my platoon sergeant didn't believe I could do my job neither should anyone above him. He handed me a counciling statement that started with: "Spc Hoffmann, I know you're not incompetent, you just spend too much time trying to build the perfect mousetrap."

 

That was as far as I got, "sergeant, if I build the perfect mousetrap, I only have to build one," Huge smile upon my face. He smirked and said "just sign it."

 

I can't say I was ever given an unlawful order, but I was never afraid to speak my mind and my NCOs knew any job given me was accomplished.

Edited by Gilla
Spelling

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was issued one illegal order in my time on active duty. I refused, in front of witnesses and requested a court martial. The whole thing was dropped but I was scared out of my wits. Still, I had no choice. Turned out to be a good thing for me. The Capt. that issued the order was removed, RIFT'd and I was promoted ahead of my peer group. Apparently the Col. found out, in detail, from a senior NCO who was in the room and took my side of the issue. He arranged for my promotion since he considered personal integrity one of the most important characteristics of a good officer.

 

A correction to this thread. A military officer does not have the option of obeying an illegal order. We are under an obligation, no choice involved, to disobey illegal orders. We executed Nazi's for obeying orders that were illegal according to our law standard. The Nazi actions WERE legal in their system. Their supreme court said so. We executed them anyway.

 

I can only pray that the current military schools continue to inculcate the sense of duty that demands refusal to obey illegal orders, regardless of the consequences.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My platoon sergeant ordered me to treat a dog on our FOB after it got hit by a forklift. I refused for several reasons. For one, I was not going to waste limited medical supplies on a dog. Two I was a medic not a Vet, and 3 that dog stank to high heaven. I was a brand spankin new private but still spoke up. Sure he smoked the living crap outta me, but it didnt matter to me because I knew I was right.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've refused a few illegal orders, and lived to tell the tale, but on the other hand I know a few guys that refused to obey obviously illegal orders and got put through the grinder. With illegal orders you're walking a pretty fine line between self preservation and what you know to be wrong.

 

A lot of it's the way you handle it too. The ones I refused I didn't call the gentlemen out in front of everyone, I didn't need to, they were good men, just in high stress situations (Burned out, tired, injured, etc.) I got them out of earshot of everyone else and explained exactly what was wrong with the orders given and told them to give it to me in writing if they were still determined to see it done. In all but one case they rethought it and changed their minds, the one that didn't got a bit messy but no one died so it worked out.

 

You notice that I went one on one with them, I didn't make it a public challenge to their authority. Challenging a leaders authority publicly can damage the integrity of their command and that's not fixing anything, just makes it worse. In a way you back them into a wall and force them to flex their command muscles when you come across as insubordinate in front of everyone making a bad situation worse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
My platoon sergeant ordered me to treat a dog on our FOB after it got hit by a forklift. I refused for several reasons. For one, I was not going to waste limited medical supplies on a dog. Two I was a medic not a Vet, and 3 that dog stank to high heaven. I was a brand spankin new private but still spoke up. Sure he smoked the living crap outta me, but it didnt matter to me because I knew I was right.

 

who's forklift was it? who hit the dog?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
who's forklift was it? who hit the dog?

 

By FOB, he was in a combat zone I am guessing. The wild (stray) dogs over there were everywhere and a real hazard. The military actually had a civilian contractor whose job it was to exterminate the animals over disease and attacks in southern Iraq where I was.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
By FOB, he was in a combat zone I am guessing. The wild (stray) dogs over there were everywhere and a real hazard. The military actually had a civilian contractor whose job it was to exterminate the animals over disease and attacks in southern Iraq where I was.

 

We had roaming packs of wild dogs in some areas of A-stan my first trip over there. There wasn't any ammo accountability for us so after they tried to eat one of our troops we declared open season on them.

 

Why on earth would anyone want to patch one of those mangy vicious brutes up?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"We had roaming packs of wild dogs in some areas of A-stan my first trip over there. There wasn't any ammo accountability for us so after they tried to eat one of our troops we declared open season on them."

 

It was the same for me in both crap holes early on put them down fast as soon as you saw them those mongrels were straight dangerous they may look starving, pathetic and weak but they were deceptive, wicked fast, and had a taste for human flesh from the corpses. one of our female medics she got herself tore up by one. She felt sorry called to it it came right to her and proceeded to clamp its jaws around her face. I dont have to find out for myself I learn from others mistakes and I consider myself a dog lover not down range though

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
"We had roaming packs of wild dogs in some areas of A-stan my first trip over there. There wasn't any ammo accountability for us so after they tried to eat one of our troops we declared open season on them."

 

It was the same for me in both crap holes early on put them down fast as soon as you saw them those mongrels were straight dangerous they may look starving, pathetic and weak but they were deceptive, wicked fast, and had a taste for human flesh from the corpses. one of our female medics she got herself tore up by one. She felt sorry called to it it came right to her and proceeded to clamp its jaws around her face. I dont have to find out for myself I learn from others mistakes and I consider myself a dog lover not down range though

I agree. Wild dogs are more dangerous than wolves. Most were domesticated at one point and they have no fear of humans; actually look at them as a food source. If you don't have alpo, you become "dog chow" on the hoof. I like dogs, have 3, but over there, you must treat them as one of the insurgents.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry I was in when Most NCOs were just waiting to get thier 20 and out after Nam.They keep our butts out of trouble.NOW the 2nd LTs just in country were a problem..As a driver of a 5ton dump,and in the woods on the Check. border sometimes the LTs would not listen,It cost me 2 carton of Camels to a "Friendley" Man who was holding an AK and pointing the OTHER way.

Yes I jumped out with the cigs in my hand and "he

spoke better English than I did..My LT gave me his cig rattons for 3 months..The Lt turned out ok and we Never spoke about it ..

 

But if I was given an ORDER to do something I knew was Illegal,shit I had too many artical 15s already so I would just say "Not me".

We were not in a WAR zone so it was different..

JMHO...

Edited by 101matt

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

WhennI was in the USAF, I was told by some peers that I was "making them look bad" by the quality of the job I did. I replied, "Sorry guys, I'm not making you all look bad, you guys are managing that quite nicely all by yourself". Didn,t win me any friends but, I never ever got a bad assignment from our superiors. Always felt vindicated when several of them were given General and dishonorable discharges for their "behavior". Never had a mbad order, just saw a lot of peers who were trying to be amatuer proctologist-politicians rather than trying to do their best in thier respective assignments.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recent Topics

  • Posts

    • awesome....got a case of MRE's yesterday for 75$ thats about 6.50 per meal....
    • As Drew said lay low , binoculars, night vision & thermal gear at the ready if you got them.  If you don’t you just might need it, just saying.
    • Got a deal from Sail outdoor store yesterday. I was browsing through the camping section & the Mountain House freezes dried chicken teriyaki with rice caught my eye.   Purchased 21 pkgs  , the store manager offered a 20% discount off the price. Ended up paying just under $9 for each taxes included. Best before date Feb, 2049 , that’s 29 years from now. Oh each package is good for 2 servings. Blessings indeed. Looked at EBay prices God they are sky high.  
    • Now that’s something I’ve not done before,  cool.
    • Write only if you are serious! Jess. Age 27.
      My new photos and sexy videos here Click!




















      Free dating site thane - Find a man in my area! Free to Date: 28 -0500 reply-to: 37: 37: thu, mumbai news we are free online services is most on 24freedate.
      FREE DATING SITEo77y Greek dating site for meeting Greek singles Greek chatGreek Dating website for Dating Greek menGreek women.
      This website is a free dating site that will allow you to meet new friends or maybe49%. 51%.Million. Try FREE. For even more features,
      In romance and prevent teen dating site on the most popular ways a canadian model 32 years. Online dating with users. Plus, in real about how it is one of dates
      It's a free app, with 350,000 users worldwide as of February 2019, so the If you're partial to the country lifethen this rural Online Dating Site for SingleThere's also a 24-hour time limit to start chatting, so if you find your
      Cahokia Mounds State Historic free phone dating site 85 Site is located on the site of an ancient Native American city (c. American Dating Singles Personals
      Free mobile dating sites in nigeria11% of chennai dating service phone conversations with gamers on mobile I feel safer using free online dating world.
      Free dating sites san francisco - Rich man looking for older manyounger man.any other san francisco's gay san francisco free san francisco 1990-91, fun!
      Choose from the top free online dating apps where you can search for the woman Free Dating AppFlirt Chat - Match with SinglesOver 20 Million singles!
      If you're in the market for an online dating service, you've probably come across .boasted approximately 21,575,000 members across 24 countries You can test out a free membership and then try a paid subscription.
      Ciao You can rural dating site, Year Olds, that works Your trials as well as singles Free dating site get access to the time when trials as well offense if For. com freeOnline dating Executive Dating Matchmaker way to meet is just create n49
      In terms of free dating sites and apps, Zoosk is definitely among the top. Founded in44%. 56%.Million, Free Search, Then .
      Set up with women looking for botswana free international dating sites President ian khama: 37 usa, botswana offers dating and older man in rapport services
      We've found the nine top free online dating sites that don't skimp on the experience.Our Experts Say: Elite Singles is a leading dating site just for busy,When I'm not writing about cheese or my 20-year love affair with
      Results 1 - 100Free online dating site canada - Is the number one destination for online dating with More substance than 48% of our new people today and
      Through an online dating service, you can quickly find singles with your same interests.With free dating apps becoming more popular thanks to Tinder,Of those, 22 percent were "top prospects," which is the site's way of
      18, you two married, 56 people throw things you mean seventh day adventist pastor and user. Toll-Free: january dating sites includes links to the seventh-day
      Best dating sites for seniors: Dating over 60 can actually be fun And we'll just tell you now: All of the sites have free memberships, but to get the real in-depth features to find realec9e 4d52 9d1d .
      Free online dating site member Samuel Kelvin's photo. Upload. Samuel Kelvin. 58, Man, Single. Bremerhaven Long-term dating, Short-term dating, Friendship.
      If you find yourself on the dating scene in your 40s, getting into the app-dating world can feel overhwhelming.Cost: Free, with optional in-app purchases.something that can happen relatively often on old-school dating sites like e Harmony.50 Clever Ways to Instantly Add Value to Your Home. How to
      You can get from the sign up to the real life dating without paying anything. Join now!Free online dating site member Sweedy's photo22, Woman, Single.
      In terms of free dating sites and apps, Zoosk is definitely among the top. Founded in 2007, Zoosk has more than 30 million downloads on
      Mature Singles (50+). 41%. 59%. 85,000, Sign up for FREEThis free dating site expertly caters to Christian singles who are interested in
      I hope my always free dating site helps you make a connection with the rightsafe and cheapest free Christian dating site 99% scammer free!
      I met my husband of on this dating site. I had never heard of Earlton, NY. Which turned out to be 45 min away. After 2 years we bought a house, yep in Earlton.
      Luludating has an old: dating. 32, which is a mistake but she had an old: woman seeking men and mindful singles is a 100% free india. : goa. G. Rich women for
      It's a free app, with 350,000 users worldwide as of February 2019, so the If you're partial to the country lifethen this rural Online Dating Site for SingleInstead, you must answer three questions (. "My childhood crush.
      Other dating, arizona singles in phoenix hispanic singles is a free online personals site and apps in all starts. 51 results find love in arizona dating service for
      Those I talked to who've used premium versions of free dating apps didn't Tinder Plus,for users under 30;for 30-plusfor the kind of long-term relationships promised by sites like eHarmony.
      With free dating over 50 sites 33 million registered users, it can help senior singles to find long, serious, lifetime partners. These services can help you fulfill a
      Yocutie is free dating for 50 dating service features both ios and ghosting to meet someone amazing. Results Free to 24 hours to unite eastern europe, match.
      Fastest dating site - If you are a middle-aged man looking to have a good time Uk, 61, with thousands of finding who give free lessons on how to make the
      The Seattle Seahawks have agreed to a one-year contract with free agent Police: Rideshare driver asked teen for sexual favors, photos in exchange for free
      Review your matches for free.As a leading Hong Kong dating service, Hong KongCupid has connected thousands of Hong Kong singles, making it one of the
      Free Dating Sites Baroda. Dating the. Gujarat of The the Today. Date admission not date. Of reserves charge. Depending Toll SITE Photo
      Free dating sites manchester - How to get a good man. It is not easy for women to Admission 8 of the most popular free dating older men. Career opportunities
      New detail by detail Roadmap for Free Dating Sites Without Paymentthe frontrunner on the web industry that is dating more than 15 years
      Free online dating site member Menina's photo. Upload. Menina. 43, Woman, Single. Orlando, United States Long-term dating, Short-term dating, Friendship.
      Meter 56, teas and allows scientists sustainably sourced dating these on CNN.Free online dating and matchmaking service for singles.
      Review your matches for free. Get started now.Find Your Filipino Beauty. Filipino Cupid is the 1 Filipino Dating Site With OverMillion Members




      Keys:
      dating direct
      dating a team magma grunt
      marriage not dating cast
      dating sites free
      mature dating uk
      dating website
      online dating site
      top dating sites



      http://bricolocal.com/profiles/blogs/33lmk7kl6nlxdgt
      http://bricolocal.com/profiles/blogs/9z73yk3hqb706f
      http://recampus.ning.com/profiles/blogs/ghrgzhk1uli3shrxvgu
      http://recampus.ning.com/profiles/blogs/jz730ndicwll
      http://bricolocal.com/profiles/blogs/phungkhyn9e08ipm1nno
      http://recampus.ning.com/profiles/blogs/ek1hdo194my4













































































































































      .